60 fall would you rather questions
Fall choices for a class, a family table or a walk in the leaves: outdoors, fall treats, cozy days, a few silly ones, then bigger choices for older kids and grown-ups. Pick one, then say why if you want to.
60 questions · Fall would you rather questions · prompts to play
Updated
No questions match these filters.
Leaves and outdoors
- 1
Would you rather jump into a giant pile of leaves or rake the biggest pile on the street?
- 2
Would you rather go apple picking or pumpkin picking?
- 3
Would you rather find your way through a corn maze or ride a hay wagon around the farm?
- 4
Would you rather find the reddest leaf in the park or the biggest leaf?
- 5
Would you rather walk through crunchy leaves or splash through puddles?
- 6
Would you rather hike to see the fall colors or have a picnic under a golden tree?
- 7
Would you rather carve a pumpkin or paint a pumpkin?
- 8
Would you rather watch geese fly south or watch squirrels bury acorns?
- 9
Would you rather win a ribbon at the fair for the biggest pumpkin or for the best apple pie?
- 10
Would you rather sleep in a tent on a chilly fall night or sit by a bonfire and sleep indoors?
Fall treats
- 11
Would you rather drink hot apple cider or hot chocolate?
- 12
Would you rather eat apple pie or pumpkin pie?
- 13
Would you rather eat a caramel apple or a bag of kettle corn?
- 14
Would you rather bake pumpkin bread or apple muffins?
- 15
Would you rather roast marshmallows or roast pumpkin seeds?
- 16
Would you rather have a bowl of chili or a bowl of squash soup?
- 17
Would you rather eat a crunchy apple or a juicy pear?
- 18
Would you rather eat cider donuts or warm cinnamon rolls?
Cozy fall days
- 19
Would you rather wear a cozy sweater or a flannel shirt?
- 20
Would you rather wear rain boots all fall or hiking boots all fall?
- 21
Would you rather read a book on a rainy afternoon or play board games?
- 22
Would you rather make a scarecrow or a leaf collage?
- 23
Would you rather hang a wreath of leaves on the door or line the steps with pumpkins?
- 24
Would you rather start the school year with new shoes or a new backpack?
- 25
Would you rather play in a soccer game or cheer at a football game?
- 26
Would you rather host a fall movie night or a fall bonfire?
Silly fall choices
- 27
Would you rather be a squirrel that forgets where it buried its nuts or a bear eating everything before winter?
- 28
Would you rather fly south for the winter like a goose or stay home and grow a thick coat like a fox?
- 29
Would you rather have leaves that turn any color you choose or a tree that grows apples and pears?
- 30
Would you rather have every day be a crisp fall day or a warm summer day?
- 31
Would you rather gain an extra hour of sleep when the clocks change or an extra hour of play?
- 32
Would you rather live on a pumpkin farm or an apple orchard?
- 33
Would you rather be a scarecrow who can talk to crows or a pumpkin that can sing?
- 34
Would you rather see the fall colors from a train or from a bike?
- 35
Would you rather build a fort from leaves or a fort from hay bales?
- 36
Would you rather rake a neighbor's leaves or make a thank-you card for a neighbor?
- 37
Would you rather help harvest a garden or plant bulbs for spring flowers?
- 38
Would you rather find a perfect acorn cap or a perfect pinecone?
For older kids and grown-ups
- 39
Would you rather spend a fall weekend driving to see the leaves or helping with an orchard's harvest?
- 40
Would you rather run a race in the crisp fall air or bike a long trail under the turning trees?
- 41
Would you rather host a Friendsgiving or go to a big family Thanksgiving?
- 42
Would you rather carve the scariest pumpkin on the street or the funniest?
- 43
Would you rather walk through a haunted house or ride a haunted hayride?
- 44
Would you rather have a fall that lasts four months or four weeks of perfect fall weather?
- 45
Would you rather drink something pumpkin spice every day of fall or never smell pumpkin spice again?
- 46
Would you rather watch every football game of the season or play in a fall soccer league?
- 47
Would you rather go to a county fair with rides or a harvest festival with music?
- 48
Would you rather make apple butter from scratch or bake a pie with apples you picked yourself?
- 49
Would you rather rake leaves for an hour or clean the gutters for twenty minutes?
- 50
Would you rather spend a fall evening around a fire pit or at a football game under the lights?
- 51
Would you rather write a spooky story or tell one aloud by flashlight?
- 52
Would you rather spend Halloween handing out candy or taking younger kids trick-or-treating?
- 53
Would you rather visit a cider mill or a pumpkin patch with a giant slide?
- 54
Would you rather see the leaves change in the mountains or around a lake?
- 55
Would you rather get the extra hour of sleep in the fall or keep the long light evenings of summer?
- 56
Would you rather have a closet full of cozy sweaters or a closet full of perfect jackets?
- 57
Would you rather learn to make a perfect pie crust or a perfect pot of chili?
- 58
Would you rather start the school year in the fall or in January instead?
- 59
Would you rather cook the whole Thanksgiving dinner or do all the dishes afterward?
- 60
Would you rather read a mystery on a rainy fall weekend or watch a whole spooky movie series?
Timer and team scores
8 turns × 60 seconds = 8 minutes of play, plus instructions and breaks.
60
Pause whenever the group needs more time.
Team Lime's turn
Team Lime: 0
Team Violet: 0
Team Tangerine: 0
Team Sky: 0
Team Lemon: 0
Team Bubblegum: 0
Use this set with a group
Read a prompt, allow thinking time, then invite an answer or a pass. For a timed round, choose a turn length before starting. A host can keep the printed answers out of view until the round ends.