The case of the missing birthday cake
What to say: “Oh no! The birthday cake was on this plate at eleven o'clock, and now it's gone. Four people were around the house this morning. Find the clues, question the suspects, and tell me who took the cake and how you know.”
Before the players arrive
- Hide the real cake where the children will not look, and leave the empty plate in the kitchen.
- Ask four grown-ups to play Bev the Baker, Gus the Gardener, Nico the Neighbor and Pat the Painter. Give each their card and their name label. Only Pat's card says who took the cake.
- Cut out the clue cards and leave each one where its card says. A few real crumbs and a dab of blue frosting on the plate make clues 1 and 2 easy to believe.
While they play
- Children search in pairs and bring each clue they find to you to read out.
- Anyone may question a suspect at any time. Suspects answer from their cards and may make up harmless details.
- When a group names the thief, ask which clue proves it. Accept the answer once they point to the blue paint on the plate (clue 2) or the brush with frosting on it (clue 6).
The answer, for the host
Pat the Painter took the cake. Pat says they never went inside, but there is blue paint on the cake plate and chocolate frosting on Pat's brush, and the crumbs lead to the back door, where Pat was painting.
The others check out: Bev's candle receipt is timed 11:05 at the shop, Nico's dog photo is timed 11:02 in the park, and Gus's trowel and tulips are at the front of the house, away from the crumbs.
Suspect cards and clue cards
Cut along the dashed lines.
Suspect
Bev the Baker
Say: "I baked the cake at seven and left it on the plate to cool. At half past ten I went to the shop for candles, and when I got back at a quarter past eleven, it was gone."
If asked for proof: "I kept the receipt. I think I dropped it in the fruit bowl."
Suspect
Gus the Gardener
Say: "I planted tulips in the front garden all morning. I never went round the back."
If asked for proof: "Go and look at the tulips by the front door. My trowel is still there."
Suspect
Nico the Neighbor
Say: "I walked my dog in the park from ten until twelve. I took a photo of him at about eleven."
If asked for proof: "I dropped the photo by the front door when I came to say happy birthday."
Suspect
Pat the Painter
Say: "I painted the back fence blue all morning. I never went inside the house, not once!"
Your secret: you took the cake. Stick to your story until someone shows you clue 2 or clue 6 and says why it proves it. Then gasp, confess, and lead everyone to the real cake.
Clue 1
Crumbs
A trail of cake crumbs from the kitchen to the back door.
Clue 2
The plate
A smear of blue paint on the edge of the empty cake plate.
Clue 3
A receipt
Corner Shop. 1 pack of birthday candles. Today, 11:05 a.m.
Clue 4
A photo
A photo of a dog in the park. Printed in the corner: today, 11:02 a.m.
Clue 5
A trowel
A muddy trowel next to a row of tulips, just planted in the front garden.
Clue 6
A paintbrush
A paintbrush with blue paint on the bristles and chocolate frosting on the handle.
Name labels
Bev the Baker
Gus the Gardener
Nico the Neighbor
Pat the Painter